Review: Sanditon

Title: Sanditon
Author:
Jane Austen
Genre:
Literary Fiction / Classic
Published Date: 1817 (unfinished)
Why I wanted to read it: I am reading the book as part of Austen in August, but I’ve wanted to read more of Jane Austen’s work since reading Pride and Prejudice years ago.

Overview

Had Jane Austen lived to complete Sanditon, it would have been as treasured as her other novels. In the half-finished masterpiece, Austen fashions one of her classic heroines—Charlotte Heywood. The surviving fragment also sets the story well on its path as Charlotte begins an adventure to Sanditon where a full cast of characters becomes intertwined in various intrigues.

Note: The below statement is also on my review of The Watsons. Disregard if you’ve already read that review.

Before I get to my reviews, I need to write about unfinished work. I find it difficult to take writing for what it is like some people do if the work is unfinished. I start to question whether or not the author would want their work published when it’s unfinished, which makes me feel like I’m invading their privacy. A part of me doesn’t want to read the work while the other part is excited to see what the author’s writing looks like unedited and unfinished. We see books today that are edited several times and perfected before being allowed on the shelf, but with some of Austen work that isn’t always the case. Love and Freindship, for example, has many spelling and punctuation errors, but we love it because it shows us a young Jane using her early wit and cleverness to keep us interested despite these errors. I can look past the errors in most cases, but I have trouble looking past unfinished work. While I’m eager to soak up every word written by Austen, I am also now left wondering about what could have come from works like The Watsons and Sanditon. Perhaps it’s just me, but I find this rather irksome. Regardless, I put my personal opinion aside and rate the work as it is, not based on what it could be or what is lacking due to being unfinished.

Review
Hypochondria at its best! I have a great fascination with hypochondriacs, and their presence in Sanditon alone makes me love the story and wish Austen had finished it. It’s difficult to be upset with her, though, considering the novel was put aside as her health was declining, followed by her death. There is a lot of question as to whether or not Austen was writing Sanditon as a way to deal with her own illness, to find humor in a serious issue. It’s somehow easier to poke fun at a serious issue when it’s happening to you, and I do believe that’s what Austen was attempting here and would have achieved brilliantly had the novel been finished.

The characters in the story go to Sanditon to get away from the old and start fresh in a place that is just as new as its inhabitants. Mr. Parker states that Sanditon is “the most favoured by nature, and promising to be the most chosen by man.” I wonder if this too relates to Austen’s dying. People oftentimes envision another place as their own personal heaven before passing away. Perhaps Sanditon was Austen’s own image of heaven, and that this was her farewell piece. Perhaps I’m going too far with such an idea, but thinking of the story reminds me of going to Neverland, which in itself is a form of heaven just as it’s a place to never grow up.

There appears to be a lot of confusion throughout the novel among the characters. The reputation of Sanditon is growing, and as more people become interested in the new town, it becomes less clear who actually knows what about Sanditon. It’s also clear that people talk about themselves a great deal when the content isn’t necessarily true. A couple examples of this are the hypochondriac Parker sisters as well as the gentleman who believes himself to be a “dangerous man” due to his being well-read in Gothic novels. Despite the humor of such characters, I have to admit that I’m more interested in the overall themes in this novel than I am the characters, but that could certainly come from the novel being unfinished.

While I generally shy away from unfinished work, I find myself most intrigued by Sanditon considering the autobiographical feel of Austen’s life. As I said with The Watsons, I think this work would have been added to the “big six” list had it been completed. Nevertheless, I will personally treasure it for both the content and its place in Austen’s life.

Favorite Quote

The more wine I drink (in moderation) the better I am.

Recommend?
Yes.

Discussion Question
Do you think Austen started Sanditon for reasons relating to her personal life, or do you think that it was because she simply had an idea for something different?

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “Review: Sanditon

    • Interesting feedback! I have never read an Austen continuation or someone finishing her unfinished work before. I think it would make me grumpy and snarky towards the author, haha. I’ve learned that this makes me a “Purist” Austen reader. I may try something one day, but it’s hard to choose since there’s so much out there.

      Like

      • Yes, there’s the one by Juliette Shapiro which I read and I think there’s another popular version by “A Lady,” which I’m still looking for. I’m curious to see if there are differences between the two.

        Yes, in a way, I’m also a purist…it’s hard not to be. But I think the Sanditon versions are more acceptable than the countless spin offs and sequels of other Jane Austen novels out there.

        Like

  1. I definitely think she was writing about what was close to home. She might have had writers block or something and started it. Or maybe she realized how too close to ome it was at the end of her life.

    I never thought I’d enjoy the sequels, but I strangely enjoy them. However, I much prefer the modern day reinterpretations or flashbacks because they’re far enough removed and don’t try to be like Austen. I’ve yet to find one written as witty as Austen actually set in the Regency period.

    Like

    • I think my only complaint about sequels or recreations is when people profit off of an idea that belongs to someone else. I know they take their own spin, but I feel like if people want to do that they should stick to fanfiction. I’m not trying to say the work isn’t good, because I’m sure in many situations it is, but I personally can’t justify spending money to read them. I hope that doesn’t sound to snooty. Also, if it’s removed enough from Austen, I could probably handle that. 🙂

      Like

  2. The only book I’ve ever read that’s considered unfinished is Canterbury Tales, and there’s just so much scholarship that by the end of it I was so overloaded with academic opinions that I felt pretty satisfied.

    What’s always interesting is reading earlier drafts of published works. I spent a semester of my undergrad holed up in Fisher Rare Books reading draft after draft of Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale; time well spent!

    Like

  3. Pingback: Weekly Round-up for September 4, 2012 « The Classics Club

  4. I agree with most of what you’ve said about Sandition. It took me ages to go through the short/unfinished story bundle, and that was mainly because I was dreading the unfinished endings of The Watsons and Sanditon. I liked the latter more, its “hypochondria everywhere!” theme was promising. The Parkers are just hilarious, as is the dowager/widow. I liked Charlotte a great deal. Indeed, who knows whether Jane Austen tried to incorporate her own ailing health and her frustrations in this story? Finally, I missed the “dangerous man” mention xD

    Like

    • I was definitely dreading the unfinished endings as well. I love a good mystery, but not this sort of mystery. I would never stop a movie in the middle if I was enjoying it, and likewise I don’t want to stop a book part way through. But c’est la vie, we can’t do anything about it now, haha.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s