Review: Northanger Abbey

Title: Northanger Abbey
Jane Austen
Literary Fiction / Classic
Published Date: 1818
Why I wanted to read it: I am reading the book as part of Austen in August, but I’ve wanted to read more of Jane Austen’s work since reading Pride and Prejudice years ago.

Overview (Barnes & Noble):

A wonderfully entertaining coming-of-age story, Northanger Abbey is often referred to as Jane Austen’s “Gothic parody.” Decrepit castles, locked rooms, mysterious chests, cryptic notes, and tyrannical fathers give the story an uncanny air, but one with a decidedly satirical twist.

What I Liked

I love Austen’s use of satire and wit, especially in her earlier novels like this one. She parodies the Gothic novel brilliantly. I haven’t read The Mysteries of Udolpho yet, but from what I’ve heard she uses it well as the source of her parody. Catherine’s paranoia due to Henry Tilney’s “ghost” story of Northanger Abbey makes me laugh, because she’s just looking for an issue to come about to feed her obsession with the Gothic novel. Then again, I wandered Bath in 2010 looking for an early 19th Century gentleman to come by on his carriage and sweep me away, so I can’t blame Catherine for waiting on novels to become reality.

Because they had such a large role in the novel, I need to write about the Thorpe siblings. While Austen characterizes them in the most spectacular way, I have a great dislike of Isabella as well as her twit of a brother, John. It didn’t take long to see through Isabella’s false pretenses. While she may appear innocent at the start, she is indeed a fortune-hunter and treacherous little creature, and that is proven when she breaks away from James Morland after hearing how little money they’ll settle down with despite her so-called love for him.

One of my favorite parts of the novel is when Isabella (finally) writes to Catherine, lamenting over the loss of James and abhorrence of Frederick Tilney. She claims to to be wearing purple because it is James’ favorite color, and she asks, or assumes, rather, that Catherine will make haste to speak on behalf of her to James. Catherine concludes to being “ashamed of Isabella, and ashamed of having ever loved her,” and states that she will not speak on Isabella’s behalf. The novel takes a real turn during this scene, because until then she had such confidence in her as well as her innocence. Considering my dislike of Isabella, I love this scene, and praise Catherine for her courage to say no.

As for her brother, well, let’s just say that he’s even more insufferable than Mr. Collins in Pride and Prejudice, and to me that’s saying something. Taking it upon himself to cancel Catherine’s plans with the Tilney’s so that she’ll spend time with him is one of the rudest things I’ve seen a “gentleman” do in an Austen novel towards a woman. The shame. The horror. Or, as I summed it up…

Yes, that says “Douche Canoe.” I’m such a classy reviewer, I know.

What I Didn’t Like
Despite my love for Bath, I thought there would be a lot more Northanger Abbey scenes. I felt almost cheated, like when you hear so much about something and become obsessed with the idea of it, but the experience – when it finally comes to pass – proves lackluster. I enjoyed the scenes, of course, but I wish there would have been more of them.

Also, if it hasn’t been made obvious, I didn’t like the Thorpe siblings. The reason why I put them in the “What I Did Like” category is because of the fact that I know Austen didn’t love them either. No one is rooting for them, at least not to my knowledge, so I can like their presence because they are so un-liked.

Favorite Character
This spot goes to Henry Tilney. While he takes pleasure in teasing Catherine and overwhelming her with the possibility of Northanger Abbey being haunted, he also has an understanding and compassionate side to him. His true feelings are not made clear to Catherine until closer to the end, but his willingness to forgive misunderstandings and continue their friendship speaks volumes. He is also one of the more constant characters, and he uses honesty instead of deceit, and that is always to be admired.

Favorite Quotes

Friendship is certainly the finest balm for the pangs of disappointed love.

There is nothing I would not do for those who are really my friends. I have no notion of loving people by halves, it is not my nature. My attachments are always excessively strong.

If I could not be persuaded into doing what I thought wrong, I never will be tricked into it.

The person, be it gentleman or lady, who has not pleasure in a good novel, must be intolerably stupid.


Discussion Question
The narrator speaks of Catherine Morland being a heroine. Do you agree or disagree, and why?


20 thoughts on “Review: Northanger Abbey

  1. Pingback: Austen in August: A Reading Event « Lost Generation Reader

  2. I can’t wait for you to read The Mysteries of Udolpho. This isn’t my favorite Austen, but it had me laughing out loud at several passages, and I rarely laugh out loud while reading. So that’s a win!! And I adore Tilney. The Thorpe siblings made me chuckle for being so ridiculous. 🙂


    • Yeah, not my favorite Austen either. I have trouble giving her work anything but 5 stars, haha. From what I’ve read, I’d put them in order of tops being Pride & Prejudice, Persuasion, Northanger Abbey, Sense & Sensibility. We’ll have to see where Emma and Mansfield Park sit at the end of the month. 🙂


  3. Also — Catherine is the heroine in her own story. Life for her is a novel-in-progress. So yes — she’s the unlikely heroine. 🙂


  4. This is the only Austen novel I haven’t gotten to! I’m not sure why, since I’ve read P&P and Emma several times…time to add it to my list. 🙂

    Also, “Then again, I wandered Bath in 2010 looking for an early 19th Century gentleman to come by on his carriage and sweep me away, so I can’t blame Catherine for waiting on novels to become reality.” Too funny!


    • Haha, I’m glad you liked that! It was one of two days during my two-week trip where I wandered off alone. I would have pitied anyone who had gone with me that day because I was so in love with Bath that I practically had fangirl moments over the cobblestones and archways..But alas, no 19th Century gentlemen.


  5. Pingback: Review: Persuasion « Lost Generation Reader

  6. Pingback: Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen

  7. Northanger Abbey is delightful for it’s parody of gothic novels, but there’s an aspect of the lady Jane’s work I enjoy even more: this book is the answer to the question, “What If Jane Austen wrote YA?”. Bear with me! John Thorpe brags about his barouche/ expensive vehicle; Isabelle plays Catherine’s silly brother while “hooking up” with the eldest Tilney, who is an even worse player (in at least one sense, even if you didn’t approve of the 2007 film); Catherine falls for a charming, mature “older” man and learns how to have a healthy relationship. Catherine is also a stand-in for the reader as an average girl who is only just beginning to find her place in the world.

    Reading NA in this context, I find the novel more enjoyable, comedic, and relatable. I’d love to see other’s opinions on this point of view. I think it’s too easy to keep reading Northanger Abbey in a certain way.


    • I am honestly not familiar enough with YA to say whether or not I agree with you, but I would also be curious as to other people’s opinions on the matter who are more familiar with YA than myself. Thank you for that assessment, though! I can say that I found certain aspects to be comedic, like what you pointed out. 🙂


  8. Pingback: A Gothic Parody from Miss Austen | Tales of the Marvelous

  9. Pingback: Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen

  10. Pingback: It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? | JMill Wanders

  11. Pingback: It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? | JMill Wanders

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s